Road Trip Ideas

RETURN TO TO THE ROAD TRIP IDEAS MAIN MENU

Salmonids:
Record Breaking Salmon and Trout of the Seway Trail
by David MacNeill Illustrations by Peter C. Thompson

Each year, thousands of anglers from all over the world visit NY’s Seaway Trail, a sportfishing Mecca, in hopes of landing trophy-sized trout and salmon—or salmonids—from majestic Lake Ontario waters and from the lake’s innumerable tributaries, as well as other inland streams and lakes. Ingredients to this success include the quality of the Trail’s watersheds and efforts of dedicated fisheries staff from the State Department of Environmental Conserva-tion (NYSDEC) who oversee the management of these highly prized salmonid fisheries. The salmonid species found along the Trail are Pacific species such as chinook salmon, coho salmon, rainbow trout (and its stream run version—steelhead), plus Atlantic salmon, lake trout and brown trout. On rare occasion, another Pacific species, the pink salmon, is caught. In headwaters of the Seaway Trail streams, brook trout, the NY State fish, are frequently caught. In addition, naturalized populations of brown trout and rainbow trout are common in stretches of these streams. Most state records for these fish were set in Seaway Trail waters.

CHINOOK: Chinook or king salmon are the largest species stocked into the Lake Ontario system and are highly prized by anglers. The Seaway Trail boasts the largest chinook salmon ever caught east of the Mississippi, weighing in at an incredible 47 lb 13 oz. They are voracious predators and eat three times their own body weight in small fish to reach these large sizes in the lake. They provide excellent lake fishing year round but are most often caught in between the spring and fall. As adults, they return from the lake into their home stream in the fall where they provide trophy fishing opportunities for stream and bank anglers. Chinooks are a large silvery fish, with spotting on upper half of body and all of the tail.

COHO: While present in smaller numbers, cohos also provide a lake and tributary fishery. Coho are smaller than chinook, averaging 7-9 lbs, but the Seaway Trail boasts a world-record coho which was caught in 1998, weighing in at 33 lb. 7 oz. Both coho and chinook salmon die after spawning. Coho are less spotted than chinooks, have a thinner tail stem and have a white coloration around the gums. Chinook have black gums.

RAINBOWS: NYSDEC stocks three types of rainbow trout, the third Pacific salmonid species found along Seaway Trail waters: domestic rainbows which reside in a lake and two stream-run or migratory types stocked into Lake Ontario waters called the Skamania, a summer run/spring spawning fish and the Chambers Creek, a winter-run/spring spawning fish. Skamanias provide late spring early summer troll fishing nearshore in the lake and summer tributary fishing. These lively fish reach the 20 lb mark. Washington strain fish also provide a lake and a stream fishery. They begin their stream run in October which peaks in November. These hard fighting fish linger in the tributaries winter through early spring, when they return to the lake. Typical sizes for these fish, depending on age range from 5 to 12 lbs.

STEELHEAD: It is estimated that 30% of steelhead in Lake Ontario waters are of natural origin. The state record rainbow was a 26 lb fish caught in Lake Ontario. Steelhead are generally a more slender fish than chinook, with a light mouth lining. Spotting on the upper half of body is distinctive and in a regular pattern on the tail fin.

LAKE TROUT: Lake trout, were once native to the Great Lakes waters but became extinct during the 1950s from overfishing predation by the sea lamprey, a primitive blood-sucking fish that was introduced into Lake Ontario during the early 1800s. Lake trout have been stocked in Seaway Trail waters since the early 1970s in an attempt to create a self-supporting population and to provide deeper water fishing opportunities. There have been some encouraging signs of successful reproduction during the last decade. Lake trout are long lived species with specimens living beyond 7 years. The Seaway Trail boasts the state record for lake trout at over 39 lbs. Lake trout are easily distinguished from other species by their pattern of light worm tracks along a green or grey background.

ATLANTIC SALMON: Historically, Atlan-tic salmon were also native and very abundant to the Seaway Trail watershed but became extinct by the late 1800s by overfishing and stream habitat changes. Atlantic salmon are stocked in smaller numbers because they are more difficult to rear in a hatchery, and relatively few adult fish return to stocking sites. Although they play a smaller role in the area fisheries, they are still highly esteemed by anglers who catch them.

The fish provides lake fishing in the spring, but enter streams between June and November where they provide a stream fishery. They are most easily misidentified with brown trout because both species have similarities in body markings but markings are reduced in the salmon. In addition the brown trout has a larger head and a stockier body build. The NY state record is 24 lbs 15 oz, caught in Lake Ontario.

BROWN TROUT: Brown trout, a Euro-pean introduction, are another important species that are eagerly sought by anglers. “Browns” tend to remain closer to shore than the other species and create an important spring fishery. Growth is excellent in the big lake as shown by their football body shape. Because they are closely related to Atlantic salmon, misidentification is common. The state record is a 33 lb fish from Lake Ontario.

BROOK TROUT, the only species that is still native to New York State are closely related to lake trout. Although reduced in numbers in certain waters, brook trout have bounced back from stocking efforts. In the Seaway Trail, brookies are found in headwaters of streams. They are the smallest salmonid species present.

PINK SALMON: Pink salmon are rarely encountered by anglers along the Seaway Trail because they are generally stocked in upper Great Lakes. Because they feed on invertebrates and smaller fish, pink salmon reach a smaller size than other Pacific species, generally less than 20 inches and around 4 lbs. Males during the spawning season take on a distinctive hunchback appearance. Pinks salmon have large spots on the back and tail.

Because these Seaway Trail fisheries are precious resources, angling regulations help conserve the fisheries by controlling catches of these species by minimum sizes, numbers harvested and fishing seasons.

One important part of these regulations is an angler’s ability to properly identify these different species because over the course of their life and between seasons, their appearances can change dramatically and can cause misidentification. New York Sea Grant recently developed some high quality artwork that will help clear up some of this confusion. Be safe, and good luck fishing in the world-class Seaway Trail waters.

David MacNeill is a Fisheries Specialist with the New York Sea Grant Extension Program at SUNY Brockport For the past 15 years, he has been actively involved in extension programs related to Lake Ontario fisheries issues including sportfish identification, proper sportfish utilization, fisheries sustainability, cormorants, and lake ecosystem changes.

Peter C. Thompson, a native of Maine, is a noted freelance artist based in Syracuse, NY. His illustrations and paintings focus primarily on fish.

RETURN TO TO THE ROAD TRIP IDEAS MAIN MENU

All Photos Courtesy © Eastman Kodak Company unless otherwise specified